Cooling the Fire

In this illuminating talk, Andrea Fella reframes our understanding of the Buddhist goal by returning to the original Pāli term nibbāna, which literally means 'cooling' rather than the commonly used 'enlightenment.' Drawing from sutta passages, she explains that this cooling refers specifically to the extinction of greed, hatred, and delusion—not the attainment of some special state, but the letting go of what causes suffering. She shares inspiring stories of two very different Burmese monks she encountered, illustrating how freedom from these afflictions can manifest uniquely in each person.

Fella addresses a crucial distinction: the heart free from greed, aversion, and delusion is not indifferent but deeply responsive. When such a heart encounters suffering, it resonates with compassion rather than contracting in resistance. She uses the metaphor of a heart like jello that vibrates and wobbles rather than shattering—one that naturally moves toward alleviating suffering without the mental pain and grief that comes from fighting against reality.

The practical instruction centers on understanding suffering rather than eliminating it. Fella describes suffering as a 'tangle' between our wholesome wishes for happiness and safety and the truths of impermanence and uncontrollability. Through mindful awareness—meeting reactive states with curiosity about their human experience—these tangles gradually loosen. Using the Buddha's analogy of shipwreck debris slowly worn away by sun, sand, wind, and water, she emphasizes the gradual, inexorable nature of this untangling, offering encouragement that even small tastes of freedom point toward the full possibility of nibbāna 'visible in this life.'

Transcript

So as Ted said, the title for this talk is Cooling the Fire. The inspiration for that name came from the word that is typically translated as enlightenment. When we talk about the Wesak Festival at the end of the month celebrating the Buddha's birth, death, and enlightenment, we typically think about the Buddha becoming enlightened, and we might think about that as being the goal for the path. When Shaila invited this group of us to teach this particular series, she asked us to reflect about the goal—what we explore, what we think of as the goal of the path, and how we might find our way towards that.

The first thing I wanted to reflect on here is the Pali word that the Buddha used for his awakening: Nibbana. The literal meaning of that word is nothing like enlightenment. I don't know how people came up with that translation or why people use it, because the word itself basically means something like cooling—the act of cooling. I was told by one colleague that this was a very ordinary word in the time of the Buddha, that you would speak about a fire cooling or the rice cooling. The nature of things when they're heated is to cool. That's just what happens when you no longer keep adding the heat. When you no longer keep adding fuel to a fire, the fire goes out, the fire cools. And so the word for this freedom that the Buddha discovered was a cooling of something.

When asked about what is cooled, I'll read some excerpts from the suttas about this word nibbana and what it means to have that freedom. These are from four different passages, but they weave together nicely:

"The extinction of greed, the extinction of hate, the extinction of delusion—this indeed is called Nibbana."

If we replace enlightenment with cooling there: the extinction of greed, the extinction of hate, the extinction of delusion—this is cooling.

"Enraptured with lust, enraged with anger, blinded by delusion, overwhelmed, with mind ensnared, one aims at one's own ruin, at the ruin of others, at the ruin of both, and experiences mental pain and grief. But if lust, anger, and delusion are given up, one aims neither at one's own ruin, nor at the ruin of others, nor at the ruin of both, and experiences no mental pain and grief. This is nibbana, immediate, visible in this life, inviting, attractive, and comprehensible to the wise."

"And for a disciple thus freed, in whose heart dwells peace, there is nothing to be added to what has been done, and nothing remains to be done. Just as a rock of one solid mass remains unshaken by the wind, even so, neither forms, nor sound, nor odors, nor taste, nor contact of any kind, neither the desired nor the undesired can cause such a one to waver. Steadfast is the mind, gained is deliverance."

"This is peace, this is exquisite—the resolution of all fabrications, the relinquishment of all acquisitions, the ending of craving, dispassion, cessation, nibbana."

This is a description of what the Buddha understood to be the freedom that the path he found offered—this release, this cooling of greed, aversion, and delusion.

In one of the Buddha's early teachings, he used the analogy of fire for greed, aversion, and delusion. He said everything is burning with the fire of greed, everything is burning with the fire of aversion, everything is burning with the fire of delusion. We could look at nibbana as the cooling of those fires.

To me this conveys something completely different than enlightenment. When I first heard the term enlightenment and started practicing, thinking maybe someday I'll attain enlightenment, I had this image of getting something, of having some particular state or being in some particular way. But these descriptions speak not of what one gains, but what one lets go of.

That is interesting because it actually leaves a lot of room for what's here. When one lets go of greed, aversion, and delusion, it doesn't look one way. The goal, or how we might manifest in the world having let go of greed, aversion, and delusion—there's a lot of room for many different ways that would look. And that, to me, is inspiring.

I met some people in Burma when I practiced there—a number of very wise and very kind and very practiced people. And they were very different. I'll share one story because it gives a little flavor.

I was practicing and supporting a retreat in the northern part of Burma in the Sagaing Hills. That particular part of Burma has hundreds and hundreds of monasteries in the hills. You can just walk in the hills and move from one monastery to another. We knew some of the monks in various monasteries in that area, so we would take hikes in the hills and go visit them. At one point we were hiking—it took about thirty minutes or so to hike to this one monastery—and we were chatting along the way. As we approached the monastery gate, one of the people who was with us, who had been to this particular monastery many times, turned to us and said, "We need to be in silence as we walk into this monastery. We need to be in silence as we walk through the gate."

And so we fell into silence. As I walked through that gate, just the setting itself was remarkable—it was nestled in a bowl with cliffs on three sides of the monastery. The cliffs had been whitewashed so that rainwater could fall down into a catchment system. Something about the visual and the feeling of walking in—I felt like I was being immersed in an ocean of tranquility. It was quite remarkable.

And then I met the monk who lived there. I became so happy just sitting with him. He was such a calm and peaceful person that I felt it was being transmitted through his very being. I was simply happy sitting in his presence, feeling so at ease and so peaceful.

We visited both of these monasteries multiple times, and I'll share one story about another monk I met there. He had a very lively mind and was so delighted by the world that he was pretty much constantly laughing. We came in one day—he was probably ninety at this point, and he had shriveled over the years that I had known him. He looked like this tiny little being sitting in his chair. We knew he had been sick, and we asked him how his health was. He just laughed and laughed. I was hearing this through a translator, but it's so interesting how I feel like I heard it directly from him. He said, "Oh yes, I've been really sick. I almost died the other day." And I thought, wow—that's a happy guy. Just something about him was so delighted, and it made you delighted to be in his presence.

In both of these cases, such different expressions of freedom. This inspires me because it points to whatever expression the release of greed, aversion, and delusion takes in each of us—I can step into whatever that is for me. I don't have to model anybody in terms of how they engage. The freedom, I think, will express itself in each of us in its own way.

In those quotes I read earlier, there are other things I find inspiring as well. The first is what the Buddha describes as his state of mind—the state of mind of one who is cooled, whose greed, aversion, and delusion has been released. He says such a person experiences no mental pain or grief.

Now, that might seem unfathomable in a way. Wouldn't one grieve if one lost a dear friend? Or saw something difficult, saw the state of our country? Isn't grief a natural response? But the grief being pointed to here, and the mental pain—this is the suffering the Buddha indicated. Included in that suffering is a form of aversion, where the mind is rejecting something, pushing something away or holding on to something.

The way things are, the way the world is—the fact that every single one of us, all of our family members, our parents, children, brothers, sisters, friends, every one of us is going to die, and we don't know the order in which it will happen—this is truth. The state of the world as it is right now has come to be. It is happening. It is truth in a way also; this is what is here.

The resistance to what has already come to be is, at least in my understanding, part of what the Buddha is speaking about in this mental pain and grief—that we are resisting what is already here, that the heart is constricted or closed or rejecting something that is already present.

What the teachings also point to is that when we see suffering happening in the world, if the heart is free from greed, aversion, and delusion, if the heart is not constricted by these forces, that heart feels the suffering very profoundly. This may require us to come to a new understanding—what it would be to feel the suffering of the world very profoundly and deeply without constriction.

The Buddha doesn't call that mental pain and grief. He calls it compassion. The heart that responds to the suffering of the world instead of fighting against it, pushing against the suffering of the world.

When the heart that is free from greed, aversion, and delusion meets suffering in the world, the way it responds is quite different. I feel like the heart that is constricted by greed, aversion, and delusion is somehow hard, encased, encrusted in a way.

It feels stiff. It doesn't resonate in sympathy with what's happening. It may shake, it may break, it may be very brittle.

The heart that has become free from greed, aversion, and delusion—my sense of that, just from little tastes perhaps, every now and then, little tastes of the heart freed from at least chunks of greed, aversion, and delusion—there's a feeling of resonance. There's a feeling of quivering. The heart resonates. It feels almost like a bowl of jello. It doesn't shatter when some kind of energy shakes it. It just vibrates and wobbles and wiggles.

So when the heart that is free from greed, aversion, and delusion is contacted by suffering, it resonates with that suffering. And it wants to act. It wants to alleviate that suffering. When that same heart contacts joy in the world, it also resonates with that very deeply, feeling the delight of empathetic or sympathetic joy.

The heart that is free from greed, aversion, and delusion is not the heart of uncaring indifference or non-action. It's the heart that is infused with the qualities of love, of compassion, of joy, of equanimity, of generosity—that connected quality.

And yet, the usual way that we engage, when our hearts are covered by greed, aversion, and delusion, when they're operating from that perspective, it's very difficult for that heart to fathom that there's something else, another way to act in the world. It's like we're blinded. The delusion embedded in aversion says, "You have to act on me in order to be okay in your life when things are difficult." The delusion embedded in greed says, "You have to follow through with me in order to be happy, in order to get the things that you want."

These states of greed and aversion have an embedded delusion in them that basically believes they are the reason why we do anything. They can't fathom that if they go away, there would be anything we would do. Wanting—the belief behind wanting is: why would I do anything if I didn't want? Wanting is not going to tell you that if it goes away, there are other beautiful motivations for life, for connection, for engagement.

The one piece that I find inspiring here is this "no mental pain and grief." What might that be? Just to contemplate what a heart free from greed, aversion, and delusion might look like—I find that inspiring to consider.

The other piece that I find inspiring is this statement: this is nibbana. This experiences no mental pain and grief. This is nibbana—immediate, visible in this life, inviting, attractive, and comprehensible to the wise. Visible in this life. To me that points to the possibility of living in the world, of being engaged in the world from this perspective of the absence of greed, aversion, and delusion.

When I think of enlightenment, I kind of envision myself floating somewhere above the planet, not really engaged. But the absence of greed, aversion, and delusion—little tastes of moments of that in life, in engagement—reveals a possibility for being in the world and cooled, free from greed, aversion, and delusion.

So what does it mean to come to this? What does it mean to find our way to become free from greed, aversion, and delusion?

Another teaching the Buddha offers around suffering makes a connection: when we are acting motivated out of greed, aversion, and delusion, we are destined to suffer. We will suffer. We may not suffer immediately, but we will. It's like we're setting into motion the seeds of suffering if we are acting out of these energies. And so there's a kind of equivalence between a mind with greed, aversion, and delusion and a mind in which there is suffering.

This is a statement of the First Noble Truth: there is suffering, the truth of suffering. And the Buddha encouraged us about suffering. The encouragement is to find our way to release from suffering, but the instructions are not "get rid of it." The instruction about suffering is to understand it.

This is our path. The whole of the Eightfold Path—wise view, wise intention, wise speech, wise action, wise livelihood, wise effort, wise mindfulness, and wise concentration—is designed to help us come to an understanding of suffering. So let's talk simply about what this means.

So what does understanding mean? In a really simple way, all packaged together with the wisdom of the Buddha and his Eightfold Path, it is a simple instruction to be aware of the arising of greed, aversion, and delusion, and to get to know what that experience is as a human experience.

This is important—that there's a sense of coming into awareness around these states of mind: greed, aversion, and delusion. Beginning to know: greed is happening right now, aversion is happening right now, delusion is happening right now.

And yet that may not quite be enough. One of my teachers has pointed out that if you go to somebody on the street who's yelling and screaming and say, "Hey, do you know you're angry?" they'll look at you kind of like you're nuts. "Yeah, of course I know I'm angry." But they're not knowing anger in the way of what is the human experience of anger. They are knowing anger in terms of what is it going to do for me and how is it going to get me what I want.

This is not the kind of awareness that is going to support becoming free from greed, aversion, and delusion, because essentially that kind of awareness of anger—how's it going to get me what I want? How's it going to help me figure out this problem or get rid of this thing or make sure that person never bothers me ever again?—if we're caught in that cycle, we are reinforcing that anger is what's going to make us feel better at some point.

We get caught on this cycle. We get angry, something happens, we yell at somebody and they go away. And so for a little while, okay, that feels better—they're gone. We've gotten what we wanted. But there's been a lot of mess put out into the world in the meantime, and we have also cultivated this quality of anger internally.

What we're asked to do, what the understanding the Buddha is pointing to when he says "understand suffering," is not to understand it only intellectually. That's helpful—it's helpful to have a framework of understanding. The Buddha taught that aversion is a form of suffering. It's useful to have that perspective. But even that isn't enough. We have to actually do the work for ourselves and begin to experience and recognize that anger itself is already suffering. The feeling of anger, the human experience of anger, hurts. It creates pain internally.

This is what the Buddha asks us to do in terms of understanding what's happening in our minds—understanding greed, aversion, and delusion. He asks us to look at the human experience. What does it mean to be a human being that's feeling greed? What is that experience of greed?

We might not usually think about that. Typically with greed, again in terms of reinforcement, we think: get what I want, that's what makes me happy. We are following through on greed. We are looking at the things that we want and saying, "Yep, that's what I need and I'm going to go after it." And in that going after, we are missing that the feeling of wanting is already painful. The feeling of wanting—when wanting springs up, there is already suffering there. There's already a feeling of lack, a feeling that something's wrong, that something's off.

As I mentioned earlier, when we are caught by that view of wanting, wanting is not going to tell you, "Oh, by the way, if you hang out long enough, wanting will go away, and that particular desire is no longer going to be a problem." Wanting is not going to tell us that.

So the instruction around exploring greed, aversion, and delusion in practice is to bring mindfulness to the experience. What is the experience of wanting? See if we can take our attention out of the thing that we want, the situation that we don't like in aversion. Take the attention out of that for a little while and turn it to the inner landscape. What is the experience that's happening inside?

Now this kind of instruction can be challenging, particularly around social injustice. It might feel like we are—when I say remove the attention from the thing that we are wanting to have or to get rid of and put the attention on the aversion itself—this is a beginning instruction.

This is an instruction that helps us become familiar with these qualities and states of mind. Over time, what we can begin to do is recognize: okay, there's this thing out here, and here's my relationship to it. Yes, I don't like that. That's happening, and it feels like a bad thing to be happening, and I don't like it. I want it to go away. So there's aversion there.

But there's also the possibility to know the aversion while we are engaged with the situation. It's almost like we've taken another step back. We have some sense of yes, there is aversion happening, and this is what that aversion is in relationship to. We may be able to recognize that the aversion puts filters on our mind and has us start to see things in a particular way. And seeing things in a particular way means we're also not seeing other things.

When we start to see the filters that aversion creates, we can begin to act in a way that takes this into account. This aversive state of mind is happening right now, so perhaps I should take some care about how I engage. As I said earlier, the absence of aversion in the face of even social injustice does not mean that we would not engage. This is hard to understand, but it is the way the heart works—when the heart does not have that encrusting of aversion and it sees suffering happening in the world, it will act.

When we're caught by aversion and thinking, "This is wrong, I hate this, I need to annihilate this situation because it is so unjust—I have got to bring everything that I have in terms of all of my anger to bear on this situation"—when we're caught by aversion, that's the belief that's operating: that this is the only way something would change, that I must act out of that aversion. It takes a little bit of a leap of faith to recognize that aversion is not the only motivator possible.

We also need a little bit of care and caution as we go through this, because looking at greed, aversion, and delusion is not a one-time thing. It's not like one look at aversion will do it for us. It's a process. There's a gradual learning and a gradual releasing of these energies. There are going to be many times when we are engaged in the world and also experiencing aversion or greed. If we can have that step back and recognize, "Yep, I'm caught by aversion right now," that can help balance the mind a little. We might recognize that part of what's going on in that mess around the aversion is also the contact with the pain, the pain of the suffering. Anger can be a kind of rejection of that pain. And yet the heart that is free from aversion is going to feel that pain and not resist it.

Embedded even in the aversive reaction, there is this movement of the heart toward wishing there not be suffering in the world, toward wishing that human beings didn't do this to each other. Recognizing that the anger is there, maybe we can connect to the thread that leads into that connection between us—the wish that beings be safe, the wish that beings have ease in their lives. Often the anger is kind of tangled up with that wish.

When it's tangled up like that, I sometimes speak about any form of suffering as a tangle between the deep, natural, human, wholesome wishes—to be happy, to be safe, to be at ease, to have health and well-being. This is the wish for mettā for ourselves. This is wholesome. And yet those wishes come into contact with the way the world is: impermanent, unreliable, uncontrollable. Our minds get it all tangled up. When that wish for safety meets the uncontrollability of life, it feels like a problem. And so there's a tangle. The threads get all tangled up.

Any kind of suffering, my sense is, is a tangle between these threads of truth—the thread of impermanent, unreliable, uncontrollable, the ultimate nature of experience—and the deep wish for happiness, well-being, safety. Our mind just cannot comprehend how these can simultaneously coexist. We might think, and I've heard people say things like this: "Yeah, I know it's all impermanent and uncontrollable, so I shouldn't want that happiness." No, that's not the way it works. That wish for happiness, for well-being for ourselves, is natural. It is not going to just disappear. There's a way we might use these truths to bludgeon ourselves: "Oh, you shouldn't want to be happy. You shouldn't want to be safe." Trying to go to emptiness or something. "Everything's impermanent. Okay, yeah, I'm okay with that." Meantime, the part of us that wants to be healthy, happy, and safe is going, "What's going on here?"

And so on the other side of it, if we are connecting to those wishes for happiness and health and safety, and we see that things are impermanent, unreliable, we might feel betrayed by the world, or might feel like the world is just wrong.

And so what might it mean to hold both of these? Because both exist—the love that's very natural, that's a part of our human wholesomeness and well-being, and these truths. The mind that can't comprehend that they can coexist gets tangled. And this is suffering. Anger is a tangle between uncontrollable and wanting to be happy, in a way we could say that.

And so we've got this tangle. We might think that what we need to do is get rid of the anger, get rid of the tangle, take some scissors, cut that knot out of the fabric. But what are we doing there? The knot is composed of these threads. The knot itself is the suffering, not the threads.

And so the practice of being with that anger, the practice of opening to it and understanding—this is the human experience of anger. My sense of that is it's kind of like a lubricant or something that allows these threads to untangle. And then we have a weave in our lives between love and wisdom. They're woven together, supporting each other and informing each other, but not tangled anymore.

So that practice of understanding suffering—that's my sense of what the Buddha is pointing to: to understand the knot has these threads, and that this can be known and seen. The understanding of that creates the conditions for the untangling. It's a very gradual untangling. And the Buddha pointed to that too, the gradual nature of the untangling.

At one point he gave an analogy of a shipwreck. Parts of a ship are strewn over a beach—the wood and the rigging, the rope. And he said the sun, the sand, the wind, the water, all act on those parts of the ship, and gradually, slowly, over the course of months, they wear away.

Unpacking that analogy a little—that's pretty much all he said, that the sun, the sand, the wind are like the mindfulness. But if we think about it, think about that rope on a beach. You go back one day and something has happened there. The day after the shipwreck, the rope is there. It's pretty solid. You can pick it up and it's hard to pull apart. Go back the next day—what's worn down? Can you see any wearing down that's happened? Probably not. But the inexorable nature of the elements acting over the course of months and months and months... you come back six months later, you try to pick up that rope and it falls apart. This is the way he described the practice working. This gradual unfolding.

Now to me, this actually is happy-producing, this gradual nature of the path, because it fits my experience. I've had a few experiences where there's a momentary seeing of something really clearly that lets something go. But the vast majority of the way the practice has unfolded has been this very gradual releasing of greed and aversion and delusion.

Sometimes I look back at something, kind of in surprise at one point, seeing a pattern. "Wow, yeah, that one—what happened to that one? I don't remember seeing it go, but I sure remember having it there." And not even being able to call it up in that moment. And it never returning. A particular hatred at a particular person. Gone. Replaced by metta. Through this gradual path.

So I have confidence in this goal stated as the absence of greed, aversion, and delusion because of seeing, in small ways perhaps, the way they are released. We get flavors of this, we get tastes of it. Maybe just in a moment, for a moment, a second of seeing how the mind, when we meet aversion or greed, some difficult reactive state, with that curiosity of, "Huh, what's this? What's this state of mind?"

When we meet it that way, there's a feeling of a little space around it—not being quite so hooked, not quite so squeezed. We feel a shift. Sometimes we might even see a particular pattern, in a moment, just let go when it's met in that way. And again, a taste, a flavor of that possibility of being free from greed or aversion or delusion.

Just a little taste gives us the sense of that possibility. We get this little taste, and in this life, this possibility opens before us.